ΣSigmaStudio Ask AI Русский Log in

[ADAU1452] transmission distance

SigmaDSP & SigmaStudio Joe_Yoon Jun 16, 2016 00:00 3 replies Original on forum ↗
Subscribe
Joe_Yoon Question
Jun 16, 2016 00:00

Hi, all

I am wondering what is the transmission distance between 2-ADAU1452 Boards.

(EVAL-ADAU1452)

- Typ/Max/Min?

Because, one of our customers asked us if it is possible to transmit at a distance of

5 meters away.

Best Regards,

Joe

DaveThib Reply
Jun 16, 2016 00:00

Hello Joe,

Should I assume you are referring to transmitting I2S?

This is a little difficult to answer because it all depends on how it is done.

Should you not convert it or add drivers, then it depends on the wires and how it is done. What is probably best to do is use a ribbon cable where you wire it alternating the strands between ground and signals. That will help go a bit longer. Then sample rate is a large factor.

I have routinely gone around maybe 10" (25cm) using just fly wires with only a ground wire or two wrapped around a cable. I have had reasonable success but only at 48kHz fs. When I try to run at 192kHz fs the audio is bad more than it works. You can move the wires around and sometimes find a position where it works so that should give you an idea that the transmission line details is vital when transmitting I2S.

On our lab test benches we have the Audio Precision serial audio interface. This uses a cable that is maybe one meter long or slightly shorter. It uses decent coaxial cables for the signals with one cable for each signal. It also has decent drive capabilities but even with these measures we sometimes have issues. We often find that the parts cannot drive the cable very well so the part being set as a master sometimes does not work. So we end up using the Audio Precision as the master.

So 5 meters I can say it would not be possible. I think you will have to design a driver PCB with buffers that have a high drive strength and are capable of driving the capacitance of a long length of coax cable or you need to translate it to a differential signal like LVDS and translate it back on the other end. I suppose you could investigate optical solutions?

Others on the forum may have better suggestions. I personally have not tried to go that far.

Dave T

matthijs Reply
Jul 27, 2016 00:00

Actually the eval board has no spare I²S outputs since the codec already uses all four output ports of the ADAU1452, with two channels each. The codec actually supports 8-channel TDM instead, which would require only one output port, but the codec's configuration SPI port isn't connected to the DSP, to a header, or even to test points. They're grounded, so no reconfiguration possible without non-trivial hardware hacking. (Nicely done that...)

Regardless, as you pointed out I²S really isn't well-suited for long distances. You'd need proper drivers and cables, and carefully match them in length to avoid timing skew. The higher the bitrate needed, this worse this will get.

S/PDIF has embedded clock and frame sync, thus avoiding those problems, and since the boards indeed have S/PDIF in and out, that would be the most obvious choice of connection. And indeed if more channels are needed and you can free up the necessary I²S ports then again using S/PDIF (with external converters) seems like a good option. Doesn't necessarily have to be optical then, you can also use balanced twisted pair (as typically used for AES3).

ADIApproved Reply
Jul 28, 2016 00:00

A2B | Analog Devices

might be an option for you.

Regards